Midi – value 128 is shown as 100 in pattern

Bug Description

The incoming midi velocity can maximum reach “100%”, but when we communicate about midi we talk about a value between 0 and 127 for Midi 1.0, not 0 – 100 %, same for any other controllable midi CC value [which is not only on/off], when it comes to using the correct terminology/measurement.

Reproduction Steps

  1. Enable recording of velocity for incoming midi.
  2. Go to pattern
  3. Record the incoming midi

Occurrence

Always

Found in

Version 1.01 for Tracker Plus.

  • Version: [example 1.8.0]
  • Build: [example 345]
1 Like

Hey @gravedraq, hope you’re well. We spoke about this in the General chat earlier.

I kinda feel that this is more of a feature request rather than a bug. I totally get that when a MIDI device is plugged to the input, then the value in percentage is confusing to know the exact MIDI value you’ve entered. The issue I see is that when you don’t have a MIDI device plugged in, volume going to 127 wouldn’t make sense.

Once thing that wasn’t covered in our earlier conversation is that if you set one of your Instruments as a MIDI channel, then the Instrument Parameters and all the assignable CCs are in the proper 0-127 format.

2 Likes

Hi @dan.lgrnd

Thank you for the reply, I hope the Polyend development team also will adapt this into the future OS pipe-line. Maybe a “mask”, where you can choose between percentage or midi 1.0 values. Similar to the options of “pattern arrangement”.

I’m still learning how to use this device and it is a very exciting journey. My current mission is to find a way, where I can replace my Akai MPC and use the Polyend Tracker as the central point of the studio. [Try something different]

If you are only “in-the-box”, then a value of 0-127 does not make much sense, I agree. In the world of hardware “outside-the-box” it does, as most of our Midi compatible instruments are following this value convention. Luckly Polyend Tracker have not adapted Midi 2.0, because then you had to hide 512 steps within a percentage between 0-100 % at some cases. :wink:

Thanks for the tip concerning setting a pattern track to a midi channel and hit [Instrument Parameters] to see the full 127 Velocity evidence. [Good to know]

Appreciate your reply. I’ll abstain from any further comment as Bug reports are not my domain, but I would encourage you to create a wish as a suggestion to implement this functionality. If it’s not clear how the wish system works here on backstage, I’m more than happy to walk you through it.

Thank you @dan.lgrnd

I have raised a wish as you recommended here:

I not fan of the current wish forum handling. Things like this would end on page 200 within short time due to end-users who are voting for bloating sound design over basic functionality. :wink:

Hi @gravedraq , thanks for your contribution here. I will close this report in favor of the wish you created. This is treated currently as by design.